Many studies have explored the impact of extreme heat on health, but few have investigated localized heat-health outcomes across a wide area. We examined fine-scale variability in vulnerable areas, considering population distribution, local weather, and landscape characteristics. Using 36 different heat event definitions, we identified the most dangerous types of heat events based on minimum, maximum, and diurnal temperatures with varying thresholds and durations. Focusing on California’s diverse climate, elevation, and population distribution, we analyzed hospital admissions for various causes of admission (2004–2013). Our matching approach identified vulnerable zip codes, even with small populations, on absolute and relative scales. Bayesian Hierarchical models leveraged spatial correlation. We ranked the 36 heat event types by attributable hospital admissions per zip code and provided code, simulated data, and an interactive web app for reproducibility. Our findings showed high variation in heat-related hospitalizations in coastal cities and substantial heat burdens in the Central Valley. Diurnal heat events had the greatest impact in the Central Valley, while nighttime extreme heat events drove burdens in the southeastern desert. This spatially informed approach guides local policies, prioritizing dangerous heat events to reduce the heat-health burden. The methodology is applicable to other regions, informing early warning systems and characterizing extreme heat impacts.